Saturday, July 17, 2010

How the iPhone 4 and iZ could cost more money for Deaf users

Let's look a little closer on this iPhone 4 and the recent iZ news on Video Relay Service (VRS) for iPhone 4 along with the reality of real time video bandwidth it can consume each minute. Let's see how this could put Deaf people at a financial disadvantage using the two technological wonders. Instead of getting overly excited, people should be concerned on how this could hurt their wallets if they're not careful.

With the recent AT&T change on how it would charge cell phone users on data download and upload it reverted to a capped usage amount for their tiered pricing plan which began last month.
For $15 a month, the DataPlus plan offers smartphone customers 200 megabytes of data. If customers exceed 200MB in a monthly billing cycle, they receive an additional 200MB of data for $15 until the end of that billing cycle. For $25 a month, consumers sign up for the DataPro plan and get 2 gigabytes of data. If subscribers exceed 2GB during a billing cycle, they will be charged $10 for an additional 1GB of data.
So, 2GB a month sounds alot doesn't it? When it comes to video downloading or uploading like real time video chat, real time video VRS, or uploading video shots to your Facebook page that 2GB limit could go fast before the end of the month is up in a non-WiFi scenario here.

Here are some numbers :
The front-facing camera resolution is 640×480. At 30 frames per second, with H.264 encoding, this would result in 5 MB per minute video.

The back-facing camera resolution is 1280×780. At 30 fps and H.264 encoding, this would be 12.8 MB per minute video (note that H.264 is generally more efficient at higher bitrates).

Netflix streaming onto an iphone would be about 2.8 MB per minute video.
Let's assume a 5 MB per minute through iZ VRS relay using the iPhone 4. Let's use the 30 frames per second (fps) standard since at a minimum for clarity sake in seeing clearly the signing a 15 fps would be required. And let's assume you only make one VRS call a day for 5 minutes which equates to 25 MB used for one day VRS call. All done on non-WiFi calls. Do that each day for 30 days you would then have used up 750 MB already, almost half of the 2 GB capped limit. But add the constant real time video chatting with your friends and any videos uploaded for email, on social networking sites, or even YouTube. Do all this along with checking your emails and surfing the internet would certainly and easily push you over the capped limit of 2 GB per month with AT&T's new tiered pricing plan for smartphones. But I think the additional use of the VRS with your smartphone streaming video could turn out to be the potential hidden killer here. And how it could help take a hit on your wallet and get slapped with overusage charges by going over your capped data limit.

Looking back now and into the future one will need to develop a strategy to prevent any possibility of going over the capped limit if you plan on getting the iPhone 4 and use iZ VRS. The key is to recognize and understand these things that could end up costing you an expensive monthly telephone bill. There are other ways to keep in contact and communicate like texting, email, or IM. After all, not everybody will use the video phone to communicate all the time. Especially not when you have AT&T and other telecommunication companies coming up with their tiered pricing plans. This marks the begining of the end of unlimited download on your smartphone. Watch your wallet.

12 comments:

Candy said...

When iPhone came out, I wanted it but, because of the cost involved, I nixed it. With this iPhone 4/ATT and ZVRS, this sounds so cool..however, If I stick with what I have now or even switch over to BB, I would still pay 29.99 a month for unlimited data plan with Sprint which also include the internet and that is a much better deal. So, yes, for those of us who are on a budget, it pays to be aware of and compare costs among different phones. iPhone4 sounds cool but, if it's going to cost an arm and a leg... yikes, I think I know what my answer would be. So, I'm waiting for the details on this new iPhone 4 coming out on July 26 or eariler via ZVRS's site. I do wonder if they are going to offer a better deal than what ATT now offers for their iPhone 4 users?

Mike said...

Well, this "unlimited" data plan will soon go away, imho. Simply because of the oncoming video smartphone that come with higher frames per second, better resolution, and greater connection to other social networking sites and even services like VRS. The disadvantaged would be those who use a smartphone for its video capability and use of VRS will simply help eat up more MB than average.

Anonymous said...

If you have job.. All hearing pay all phone bills. Stop be like a poor deaf want free. Grow up!

spherescamp said...

iZ uses FaceTime, right? In order to use FaceTime, you have to be connected to a WiFi network. I have confirmation from an Apple employee that using FaceTime, connected to a WiFi network does not count against your data plan.

So while I agree that this is something to keep an eye on if they do eventually allow FaceTime to be used over a 3G or 4G network, right now it is a non-issue.

Anonymous said...

Hi Mike: thanks for the heads up. I just got my iPhone 4 last week. I have the AT&T TAP data-only plan for 2GB for $45/mo. That is an acceptable price point for me since my old pager cost me $40/mo. Even tho 2GB still sounds like a lot, I have no plans to communicate via video or Facetime with it on a daily basis. Text, email, Internet, and IM are sufficient 99.99% of the time. English is my first language so I don't need to rely on VRS when text is available. the iPhone is an extremely sexy piece of tech and absolutely lives up to all the hype. even AT&T stepped up to the plate by accepting my TAP application on a matter of hours. oh, and one fun bit of tech: the Google search app has speech recognition capability so that you can say the word of what you're looking for, like "hamburger," and call up a list of hits. I was surprised that Google could even understand my deaf speech! of course, it made more mistakes than got it right. pretty hilarious how often it thought I said words that cannot be printed in a family newspaper. *ahem*

Patty

Rob said...

Or for a fiscally sound advice: stop using or depending on video online too much.

Stick with real-time texting or email for communication, until the American Internet infrastructure (networking, fiber optics, etc.) must be redone from the ground up.

Mike said...

Patty, yes. It's relatively cheap now but the video downloand and uploading and all other kinds of internet-interaction will simply continue to eat more MBs or in this case more GBs in the short few years ahead of us. That's the point I was getting out. It's not now you have to worry, it's the coming years.

The telecommunication companies will revert to a tiered pricing plan. AT&T is already doing this. Others will follow. The infrastructure currently cannot adjust adequately to the huge bandwidth of internet data due to video uploading and downloading. With the newer smartphones that are becoming more "video savvy" the telecommunication companies are at a cross road on how to handle the increasingly influx of internet traffic.

Anonymous said...

I question the dependability and quality of video transmitted via 3G. PCWorld August issue had an article about EVO 4G video being choppy on the 4G network. Are people being conned into believing Facetime video relay can be done on 3G when it is really done on WiFi?

Mike said...

Video quality will improve over time. Advancing technology will assure that.

Jared Evans said...

I went into some more details with more accurate numbers:

http://www.jaredlog.com/?p=1150

Anonymous said...

I sure lucked out when I signed up for unlimited data plan on the last day before AT&T switched to 2gb a month limit. I am locked with the unlimited plan. I pay roughly $55 a month for unlimited data and unlimited texting but no talk minutes.

myVRS Relay Central said...

Updated about the AT&T Unlimited plan for people with disabilites can be found at:

http://www.myvrs.org/blog/2010/07/iphone-4-unlimited-data-plan-tap-update-from-att/

This may explain you are able to keep your unlimited plan as well.