Last year in March
I covered a petition that was against the show "
Switched at Birth" simply because some of the cast of characters weren't "Deaf enough." That is not enough deaf people (as opposed to hard of hearing) who are native signers. The petition provided insight to the amount of shallowness and cruelty considering the fact that the show's main cast of characters have more culturally deaf characters who are native signers and more hearing characters who pick up sign language for the benefit of their deaf sibling, deaf child or deaf friend (such as the hearing character, Bay, who was dating Emmet) than there are hearing characters who do not know sign language. The show is actually a great example of what diversity is like among the main cast of characters who are culturally deaf, hard of hearing, hearing, signers and non-signers. You can thank
Marlee Matlin for that.
She also pointed out that until recently, deaf characters were generally
a guest role written in to just a handful of episodes at best. She
credits Marlee Matlin, who plays a mother of Daphne's friend, making a
difference, saying, "[She] really did an incredible job of paving the
way for deaf actors."
But she noted that "Switched at Birth" has taken the progress one step
further. "You get four characters with hearing loss, and different
ranges of hearing loss, and it really accurately represents the culture,
the issues within the culture, and the way people feel about the
culture."
You have
three main characters who commonly appear on the show who are culturally deaf and they are Emmet (Sean Berdy), Travis (Ryan Lane), and Melody (Marlee Matlin). The other deaf/hh (main) character is Daphne (Katie LeClerc) whose grew up speaking and listening as a hard of hearing person that wears a hearing aid and knows sign language. Whenever deaf characters speak to each other the audio is edited to remove all background
noise except for ambient noise. This allow viewers to focus on the
visual emotions and physical nature of sign language while at the same time provide a perspective of what it is like to be deaf and not hear sound around them.
Rob Nielson, a
Deaf ASL teacher in Texas, was the
original author of a petition (with a paltry 100 signatures) against the show reasoning that the show isn't suitable to be shown on the
ABC Family channel tv show because
"the main Deaf character isn't even Deaf and a so-called "family channel"
is resorting to scenes of drug use, sexual innuendos, and in a recent
episode, gratuitous teen sex."
Yet in the petition it was made more abundantly clear it was more about the main character (Daphne) wasn't "Deaf enough" for Rob and his students.
ABC Family first dropped the ball by hiring an actress who is not Deaf.
Katie Leclerc is an actress that only recently started losing some of
her hearing due to Meniere's Disease. The only reason she knew any ASL
before the show was because she took it in high school and that was
because, In her own words, "I was very bad at Spanish." Leclerc has to
take voice lessons in order to "sound Deaf" on the show. Leclerc
portrays herself as an ambassador of the Deaf community - "I feel
comfortable in the deaf world I feel comfortable in the hearing world,"
Leclerc said. "I'm glad I can cross over." - There is no crossing over.
She is a hearing person that is playing the part of a Deaf character.
She is not a part of the Deaf world. Thus, some of the things about her
character are not things that are normal for a Deaf person who grew up
in the Deaf world - such as her ability to lipread flawlessly, her
constant sim-com (talking and signing at the same time), and her signing
being jerky and awkward at times. There are many talented and beautiful
culturally Deaf actresses that ABC Family could have hired.
The part about that Katie LeClerc is a hearing person is
absolutely false.
Katie Leclerc is hard of hearing in real life
Playing a deaf girl comes more naturally to Leclerc than it would to
most actors because she has first hand knowledge of what it's like to
live with hearing loss. At the age of 20 the actress was diagnosed with
Ménière's disease. She explained the affliction, "[It's] a problem with
fluid retention in the inner ear. You get fluctuating hearing loss,
attacks of vertigo, ringing in the ear, and pressure in the ear. So it
is a very sporadic disorder. The attacks come and go as they please with
no rhyme or reason."
And although the condition sometimes makes it difficult for Leclerc to
work, she never loses sight of the important role hearing loss has had
for her as an actress. "Without the Ménière's disease, I would not be
able to play the role of Daphne. In the deaf community, in order to play
a role of someone with a hearing loss… you have to have hearing loss.
So without this Ménière's disease, I wouldn't be able to have this dream
come true, this role of a lifetime, this incredible opportunity."
She found out she has Meniere's Disease at 20 years old that explained her losing her hearing which gets progressively worse as she gets older.
Katie LeClerc made clear that she is in fact a hard of hearing person, and not a hearing person that Rob is claiming. She made no claims of being an "ambassador of the Deaf community," either. That was
Rob Nielson's doing by turning it into a something else to suit his own agenda (of insecurity).
According to Don Grushkin and other culturally deaf people they would agree that Katie LeClerc is a Deaf person (
go here and
here to see why) with "Deaf" to mean an all-inclusive word. But according to Rob Nielson he is basically saying that Katie LeClerc's character, Daphne, is not "Deaf enough" solely on the basis that the character does not behave like some culturally deaf, native signer as clarified in
Rob's petition.
She is a hearing person that is playing the part of a Deaf character.
She is not a part of the Deaf world. Thus, some of the things about her
character are not things that are normal for a Deaf person who grew up
in the Deaf world - such as her ability to lipread flawlessly, her
constant sim-com (talking and signing at the same time), and her signing
being jerky and awkward at times. There are many talented and beautiful
culturally Deaf actresses that ABC Family could have hired.
Which is it, Rob? Accept a deaf/hh character (or for that matter in real life a deaf/hh person) for who he/she is or get nit-picky because the character doesn't sign flawlessly or smoothly enough for you? On the show you have three characters who sign "flawlessly" that fits Rob's ideal world and you have one hard of hearing character who does her best at signing to communicate yet her signing does not fit Rob's level of signing proficiency because, ya know, she's all jerky and stuff.
Again, Katie LeClerc is most definitely NOT a hearing person but hard of hearing.
Maybe it's time Rob, the "Deaf ASL teacher of Texas," the fair and "open-minded one," should publicly apologize for saying that Katie LeClerc is not a deaf/hh person and that her character is not "Deaf enough" because she's not like Marlee Matlin who can sign "flawlessly"?
This is deaf identity politics at its worse. That kind of ugly discrimination need to stop.